Menus
Set Sail
-
Broiled Oysters*
Local West Robin's Oysters, bacon chimichurri, shaved peppercorn asiago
$18.00
gluten free
-
Crab & Cheese Stuffed Soft Pretzels
Warm soft pretzel sticks, jumbo lump crab, beer cheese sauce, melted fontina
$17.00
-
Captain's Calamari
Golden fried calamari, lemon pepper dust, basil pomodoro marinara
$18.00
gluten free
-
Pastrami Ribs
Brined & smoked baby back ribs, bacon beer kraut, sweet whole grain mustard sauce, toasted rye crumble
$20.00
-
Smoked Jumbo Wings
Hard cider brined wings, lemon pepper dust, sautéed cherry peppers & onions, chili crisp ranch
$16.00
gluten free
-
Lobster Mac N' Cheese
Maine lobster, captain's cheese sauce, voodoo cheddar crumble, truffle hot sauce drizzle
$24.00
-
Lobster Hushpuppies
Fresh lobster, roasted corn, palmetto farms corn flour, jalapeno honey dipping sauce
$18.00
gluten free
-
Oysters on the ½ Shell*
Local West Robins oysters, kickin' cocktail
$18.00
gluten free
-
Country Brussels
Crispy Brussels sprouts, diced country ham, cider butter, pepita biscoff crumble
$17.00
-
NE Clam Chowder
Chopped Littlenecks, classic seafood cream, smokey bacon bits, diced Yukon Golds
~ Harborfest 2024 ChowderWinner! ~$12.00
Sheet Creasers
Gluten free bread available upon request +$2; our "voodoo breading" is gluten free-
BBQ Pulled Pork Melt
Smoked pork shoulder, melted cheddar, pickle chips, fried shallots, Alabama slamma' sauce. Texas toast
$20.00
-
Fried Flounder Sandwich
Voodoo breaded flounder, champagne tartar, seeded rosette bun, lettuce, tomato
$21.00
-
Main Sail Burger*
Schiavoni's "Main Street Blend" beef, sesame rosette bun, lettuce, tomato, choice of cheese
$19.00
Avocado $3.00
Bacon $3.00
-
Noyack Hot Chicken Sandwich
Voodoo breaded chicken thighs, sweet heat sauce, seeded rosette bun, pickle chips, shredded lettuce, jalapeno honey aioli
$20.00
-
Blackened Mahi Reuben
Cajun caramel mahi-mahi, captain's slaw, melted Swiss, coast remoulade, toasted thick-cut rye, old-bay fries
$24.00
First Mates
Comes with kid's drink and chocolate fudge bar; substitute mixed vegetables for French fries +$2-
Chicken Fingers
3 buttermilk fried chicken strips, plain French fries
$13.00
Adult size + $5.00
-
Fish Sticks
Golden fried cod sticks, homemade tartar, plain French fries
$14.00
-
Kid's Burger
3 oz burger, choice of cheese, plain French fries
$13.00
-
Grilled Cheese
Texas toast, melted American, plain French fries
$12.00
-
Kid's Pizza
Flatbread pizza, melted fontina, homemade tomato sauce
$12.00
-
Kid's Pasta
Elbow macaroni, melted butter or marinara
$10.00
Gluten free pasta available + $2.00
Starboard Sauces
All $2 Each-
Chili Crisp Ranch
$2.00
-
Champagne Tartare
$2.00
-
Kickin' Cocktail
$2.00
-
Roasted Anchovy Caesar
$2.00
-
Jalapeno Honey Aioli
$2.00
-
Alabama Slamma' Sauce
$2.00
-
Au Poivre Sauce
$2.00
-
Hot Honey Dijon Vinaigrette
$2.00
-
Coast Remoulade
$2.00
-
Sweet Heat
$2.00
-
Truffle Ketchup
$2.00
-
Apple Cider Demi-Glace
$2.00
Light Breezes
-
Harvest Salad
Organic greens mix, local apples, crumbled gorgonzola, toasted pecans, bacons bits, hot honey Dijon vinaigrette
$17.00
Add
Chicken $8.00
Shrimp $10.00
Blackened Mahi $14.00
Entrée Size Available $6.00
-
Captain's Caesar
Crisp romaine, sourdough garlic & herb croutons, grated cotija cheese, roasted anchovy Caesar
$16.00
Add
Chicken $8.00
Shrimp $10.00
Blackened Mahi $14.00
Entrée Size Available $6.00
Open Waters
-
Stuffed Flounder
Fresh local flounder, shrimp crab & scallop stuffing, roasted red potatoes, green beans amandine, lemon beurre blanc
$34.00
-
Jack's Fish Tacos
Daily "fresh catch", apple brussel slaw, caramelized butternut squash, coconut sage gastrique, alfalfa sprouts, warm corn tortilla, sweet po-tater tots "fresh catch" can be seared or fried
$29.00
-
Chicken & Biscuits
Smoked chicken leg, apple brussel slaw, pumpkin spiced biscuits, cider butter, hot honey drizzle
$28.00
-
Shrimp & Grits
Sautéed black tiger shrimp, smokey bacon bits, trinity veg, rich brandy cream, cheesy palmetto farms grit cake
$32.00
gluten free
-
Beer Battered Codfish
Fresh cod filet, kidd squid ipa batter, seasoned potato wedges, champagne tartar, cornichon pickles
$30.00
-
Breaded Bone-In Pork Chop
Crispy pan-fried pork chop, apple bacon jam, butternut squash, warm farro risotto, roasted heirloom carrots, apple cider demi-glace
$32.00
-
Skillet Seared NY Strip*
12oz grass-fed Angus strip, seasonal vegetable, roasted red potatoes, captain's au poivre
$44.00
gluten free
-
Shredded Duck & Sweet Potato Gnocchi
Braised Long Island duck, handmade sweet potato gnocchi, golden raisins, roasted beets, toasted pine nuts, sage brown butter
$33.00
Port Sides
-
Old Bay French Fries
$6.00
-
Captain's Slaw
$5.00
-
Roasted Red Potatoes
$7.00
-
Sweet Po-Tater-Tots
$8.00
-
Pumpkin Spiced Biscuits
With cider butter
$7.00
-
Green Beans Amandine
$8.00
-
Butternut Squash Farro Risotto
$8.00
-
Apple Brussel Slaw
$7.00
-
Cheesy Grit Cake
$6.00
-
Seasoned Potato Wedges
With truffle ketchup
$7.00
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.*
18% gratuity added to parties of 8 or more; prices reflect a 3% cash discount
Non-Alcoholic Fare
-
Mango Bango
Mango purée, simple syrup, fresh lime juice
$8.00
-
Prickly Fizz
Prickly pear purée, cranberry juice, simply syrup, topped with seltzer
$8.00
-
Lavender Chai Matcha
Chai matcha, milk, lavender syrup, lavender foam
$9.00
-
Harvest Punch
Apple cider, grapefruit juice, topped with blood orange ginger beer
$8.00
-
Strawberry Hibiscus Arnold Palmer
Strawberry purée, hibiscus syrup, fresh lemonade, unsweetened iced tea
$8.00
-
Soda & More
Saranac root beer, cola, diet cola, lemon-lime, gingerale, iced coffee, sweet tea, unsweetened iced tea, lemonade, orange, pineapple, cranberry or apple juice
$4.00
-
Fresh-Made Lemonades
Passion fruit, strawberry, mango, hibiscus, prickly pear, lavender
$6.00
Non-Alcoholic Specialty Cocktails
-
Frostbite
Prickly pear purée, coconut milk, topped with seltzer
$8.00
-
Cherry Pom Spritz
Tart cherry juice, pomegranate juice, simple syrup, topped with seltzer
$8.00
-
Winter Punch
Pear purée, black currant juice and preserves, topped with fever blood orange ginger beer
$8.00
-
Mango Bango
Mango purée, simple syrup, fresh lime juice
$8.00
Draft Beer
-
Sam Adams Seasonal
$8.00
-
Guinness
$8.00
-
Peroni
$8.00
-
Modelo
$8.00
-
Miller Lite
$6.00
-
Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
$8.00
Bottled Beer
-
Magners Cider
$7.00
-
Heineken
$7.00
-
Corona and Corona Light
$7.00
-
Michelob Ultra
$6.00
-
Coors Light
$6.00
-
Budweiser
$6.00
-
Amstel Light
$7.00
-
Montauk Pilsner Can
$3.00
-
Heineken 0.0 and Peroni NA
$7.00
Seasonal Cocktails
-
Jack Frost
Bourbon, peach schnapps, triple sec, cranberry and orange marmalade, fresh lime and orange juice
$16.00
-
Guava Sidecar
Cognac, Grand Marnier, fresh lemon and orange juice, guava purée, simple syrup, sugar rim
$17.00
-
Merry Cherry Spritz
Aperol, tart cherry juice, Prosecco, topped with seltzer
$15.00
-
Prickly Margarita
Tequila, prickly pear purée, fresh lime juice, simple syrup
$14.00
-
Mocha Espresso Martini
Van Gogh dark chocolate vodka, Tia Maria cold brew liqueur, Bailey's, espresso
$19.00